Let's start with a loud and bold statement:
Cancel culture has created a pervasive silence in the sexuality and wellness industry.
Fear of backlash and being “cancelled” prevents many professionals from speaking out against questionable practices, pseudoscience, or inflated claims. As a result, the industry’s reputation suffers, and clients may fall prey to misleading information. This self-induced censorship hampers the quality of discourse and stifles growth.
Instead of engaging in meaningful debates, many are afraid to voice concerns or critique new trends, labelling practices, or "innovations" that may lack scientific support or are merely reinvented concepts with new catchy names. This climate of suppression does more harm than good. It perpetuates the sale of dubious solutions to clients, leading to disappointment or even harm when their issues are not effectively addressed. When bad practices go unchecked due to the fear of criticism, the entire field loses credibility, and professionals are discouraged from sharing honest perspectives.
The Need for Safe Spaces in Professional Dialogue
A crucial step towards overcoming this problem is to establish genuinely safe spaces within the community for discussing these issues openly. The term “safe space” should not just be about avoiding discomfort but about creating environments where all perspectives, even dissenting ones, are welcome. Professionals must distinguish between constructive criticism and destructive behaviour, such as personal attacks or cancelling colleagues without meaningful discussion.
When we address questionable practices or raise doubts about newly coined terms, or even ideologies, it should come from a place of wanting to advance the field. Critique should be based on evidence, thoughtful reasoning, and the intention to improve client outcomes. This contrasts starkly with the rampant "pile-ons" often seen on social media, where disagreement is met with accusations rather than reasoned responses.
Why Constructive Debates Matter
Constructive debate is the lifeblood of any evolving field, including sexual health and wellness. When professionals can safely share doubts, present alternative views, and engage with critics, it raises the standards for everyone. It encourages practitioners to refine their methods, seek better evidence, and be transparent with their clients.
Healthy discussions challenge us to substantiate our beliefs and question our assumptions. They enable growth by illuminating areas that require more research, nuanced understanding, or different approaches. Suppressing dissent not only stifles innovation but also creates an echo chamber where harmful practices can thrive unchallenged. Ultimately, it's the clients who pay the price for this silence, receiving treatments or guidance that may not be based on the best available evidence.
How Can We Create Safe Spaces for These Conversations?
Encourage Transparent Communication: Establish norms where professionals can voice concerns or critiques without fear of immediate backlash. This includes understanding that disagreement is not synonymous with disrespect.
Set Ground Rules for Discussions: Agree on guidelines that prioritize evidence-based critique over personal attacks. Professionals should be prepared to back up their claims with data, studies, or clinical experience.
Embrace Diverse Perspectives: Different backgrounds bring different insights. Whether it's from life coaching, psychology, or sexological bodywork, diverse perspectives help enrich the conversation. Everyone should feel welcome to share their approach and rationale.
Avoid Absolutism: Refrain from taking rigid stances or resorting to all-or-nothing thinking. This fosters an environment where evolving practices can be adapted rather than entirely dismissed.
Establish Moderated Forums for Discussion: Consider creating panels or moderated groups where professionals can debate sensitive topics. This ensures discussions stay constructive and focused on improving practice.
Building Your Own Ability to Be a Safe Space
As practitioners, it's not just about finding safe spaces but also about becoming one. Commit to responding thoughtfully to differing opinions. Recognize when a peer is offering constructive feedback and resist the urge to be defensive or dismissive. If we aim to break the silence and foster a healthier industry culture, each of us must cultivate our ability to be open to critique and engage in meaningful dialogue.
Ultimately, the goal is to create a community that holds itself to high standards of evidence and compassion. The quality of our work depends on our ability to speak up, refine our methods, and learn from one another. By embracing constructive debate and rejecting the extremes of cancel culture, we can ensure that our clients receive the best care possible.
Final Words
Let's not just talk about change—let’s act on it. Join our events, network with fellow professionals, and be part of building a more resilient, open, and supportive community. Attend discussions where challenging questions are welcomed and work towards a culture where silence and fear no longer dictate our conversations. Together, we can set a new standard for the industry and help each other—and our clients—thrive.
Comments